top of page

Why Being Right Can Cause Problems

Nov 9
6 min read

And what can you do differently


Have you ever tried to explain something that upset you, only to have the other person immediately tell you why you shouldn't feel that way?


Perhaps you said, “I was disappointed that you didn't call,” and they respond, “Ah, sorry, I was busy.”

Or you tell someone that something they said upset you, and they explain why they didn't mean it that way.

Their explanation makes sense.

But it doesn't necessarily make you feel any better.


In fact, you may end up feeling even more frustrated because what you wanted was for them to understand how you felt.


And this is exactly where communication can go wrong.

When someone tells us they're upset, our first instinct is often to defend ourselves, explain our intentions or correct their version of events.

We start with a “Yes, but…” before we've really heard what they're saying.

We might think we're having a conversation, but the other person can experience it as a rejection of their feelings.


What if there were a different way to respond?

One that doesn't mean you are agreeing with everything the other person says, or giving up your own point of view?


The problem with “Yes, but…”

Think about how it feels when someone responds to something you've said with “Yes, but…”

The first word sounds as though they're acknowledging you. But the “but” often wipes out whatever came before it 9even if they don't actually use the word 'but')

“I understand you're upset, but…”

What we're really communicating can sound more like, “I understand you're upset, but here's why you shouldn't be.”

This doesn't mean we intend to be dismissive of the other person.

Often, we're simply trying to explain ourselves.


Perhaps we feel accused or misunderstood.

Maybe we think they're being unfair, and we want to put our side across before they reach the wrong conclusion.

The difficulty is that we can become so focused on defending ourselves that we miss what the other person is actually trying to tell us.


And the more we defend, the more likely they are to defend themselves.

Before long, neither person feels heard.


Validation doesn't mean agreement

They want validation and we want to defend ourselves.

One of the biggest misunderstandings about validation is that people think it means agreeing with someone.

It doesn't.

You can acknowledge that someone feels hurt without agreeing that you intended to hurt them.

You can understand why someone is frustrated without agreeing with their interpretation of what happened.

Validation simply means recognising that the other person's experience is real for them.

I will repeat that.

Validation simply means recognising that the other person's experience is real for them.


For example, imagine your partner is upset because you made a joke in front of friends. You thought it was funny and didn't intend to embarrass them.

Your immediate response might be:

“But it was only a joke. I didn't mean anything by it.”

That may be true. But it doesn't acknowledge how the joke landed for them.

A different response might be:

“I can understand why that embarrassed you. I didn't see it that way at the time, but I can see how it felt for you.”

You haven't agreed that you were deliberately unkind.

You haven't had to abandon your own perspective. You've simply acknowledged theirs.

That creates a much better starting point for a conversation.


We all see things differently

We often assume that other people will interpret a situation in much the same way we do.

But our reactions are shaped by our backgrounds, experiences, beliefs, values and even our sense of humour.

Something that seems harmless to one person can be upsetting to another.

Something one person considers funny might feel hurtful to someone else.

Neither person necessarily set out to cause a problem.

They simply experienced the same situation differently.

This is particularly important in relationships.

We can spend a lot of time arguing about who was right, who was wrong and what actually happened.

But sometimes the more useful question is: How did this situation feel for each of us?

Two people can have very different experiences of the same event.

Recognising that doesn't mean there are no facts, or that every behaviour is acceptable.

It means we don't have to dismiss someone's feelings simply because we would have reacted differently.


Why do we become so defensive?

It's often much easier to validate someone when we're not personally involved.

If a friend tells us their boss has upset them, we can usually listen, acknowledge their frustration and see things from their point of view.


But when someone tells us that we've upset them, something different happens.

We may feel criticised, blamed or judged.

We want to explain what really happened, defend our intentions or point out where they're wrong.

Psychologists have studied how we respond when information challenges the way we see ourselves.

Cognitive dissonance describes the discomfort we can experience when something conflicts with our beliefs or self-image.

For example, we may see ourselves as considerate and caring.

So when someone says we've been thoughtless, it can be difficult to take that in.

We want to defend the person we believe ourselves to be.


But there is a difference between being a caring person and getting everything right.


We can have good intentions and still upset someone.

We can believe we've done nothing wrong and still need to understand the effect our actions have had.

If we can tolerate that uncomfortable moment without immediately defending ourselves, we give ourselves a chance to hear what the other person is saying.


From defending ourselves to working together

The aim of a difficult conversation doesn't have to be proving who is right.

It can be about understanding each other and working out what needs to happen next.

One simple way to change the direction of a conversation is to acknowledge the other person's perspective before sharing your own.

Instead of:

“Yes, but that's not what happened.”

Try:

“Thanks for explaining. I can understand that's how you saw it. Can I explain how it looked from my side?”

Or:

“I can see why that upset you. I'd like to share what was going on for me at the time.”

The difference is small, but important.

You're not giving up having a different opinion.

You're allowing both people to be heard.

And it works both ways.

If you want someone to understand your perspective, it helps to show that you're prepared to understand theirs.

This is what collaborative communication is about.

Rather than treating a disagreement as a battle between two people, you approach it as something you can work through together.


What does this have to do with our needs?

Feeling heard and understood is an important part of our relationships. I

t's something we all need, even if we don't always know it! (And we often don't; most people don't)

Through the Whole Needs© approach, we look at what sits underneath our reactions.


Sometimes, when we become defensive, it's because we feel criticised, misunderstood or not respected.

We may be protecting a need that's important to us, but our reaction can make it harder for the other person to understand that.

The same applies when someone is upset with us.

They may need to feel heard, acknowledged or considered before they're ready to listen to our explanation.

When we take the time to understand what's happening for both people, we have a much better chance of finding a way forward.


The psychology behind validation

There is research to support the importance of validation.

A 2022 study by psychologists Kuo et al. examined how people responded to validating and invalidating feedback about their emotions.

The findings suggest that invalidating responses can increase negative emotional reactions, while validation can help people feel more understood.


It reinforces something quite simple.

When people feel dismissed, their emotional response can intensify.

When they feel heard, there is more opportunity for the conversation to move forward.

Validation doesn't solve every disagreement.

But it can change the way we approach one.


In summary

The next time you're in a disagreement, try to notice whether you're listening to understand or listening so you can defend your position.

Here are three things to practise.

1. Leave out the “but”.

When you feel the urge to say “Yes, but…”, pause. Try acknowledging what the other person has said first. You can still explain your own perspective, but give theirs some space before you do.

2. Separate understanding from agreement.

Remind yourself that you don't have to agree with someone to recognise how they feel. Try saying, “I can understand why you see it that way,” or “I can see that was upsetting for you.”

3. Practise on easy, less intense or emotional situations.

You don't have to wait for a big disagreement. Practise listening without immediately correcting, explaining or defending yourself in everyday conversations. These habits take time to change, so start with the small moments.


We all want to be heard. But sometimes we become so busy making sure the other person understands our point of view that we forget to understand theirs.


The next time you find yourself saying “Yes, but…”, try something different.

You might be surprised how much difference it makes when the conversation becomes about understanding each other rather than deciding who's right.





Psychology reference

Kuo, J. R., Fitzpatrick, S., Ip, J., & Uliaszek, A. (2022). The who and what of validation: An experimental examination of validation and invalidation of specific emotions and the moderating effect of emotion dysregulation. Borderline Personality Disorder and Emotion Dysregulation, 9, 15.


+1


Recent Posts

See All
Motivation works the opposite way

Why is it so hard to get started on some tasks, even when you know they need doing? You tell yourself you'll do them later, when you have more energy or feel more motivated. But what if something els

 
 
 
Why do we put up with things

Why do we put up with things that bother us, sometimes for months or even years, before finally saying enough is enough? And why does it often take one relatively small thing to trigger a big reaction

 
 
 
How Can We Make Change Easier?

Why is it so hard to change, even when we know we need to? You can have the best intentions and still find yourself doing exactly what you promised yourself you wouldn’t. It’s not simply a lack of wil

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page