What is the fallout from saying "I'm Okay"?
“How are you?” “Fine, thanks!”
It’s one of the most automatic exchanges in everyday life.
A friend asks how we are, we say we’re fine, and the conversation moves on.
We might be exhausted, worried, hurt, overwhelmed or quietly struggling with something that has been weighing on us for weeks.
But fine is the answer we give.
Sometimes we say it because we don't want to burden anyone.
Sometimes we don't know how to explain what we're feeling.
Sometimes it feels too private...we can come up with many reasons!
And sometimes, we've become so used to putting on a brave face that we've stopped questioning whether we should.
But what happens when pretending to be fine becomes so familiar that we stop acknowledging how we really feel, even to ourselves?
The illusion that everyone else is fine
Look around and it can seem as though everyone else is managing life perfectly well.
Your colleague gets through the working day, your friend seems happy, other parents appear to have everything under control, and social media is full of smiling faces and exciting experiences.
Meanwhile, you're trying to keep up with everything on your own list.
The problem is that we're comparing our internal experience with everyone else's external presentation.
We know our own worries, doubts and disappointments, but we only see what other people choose to show us.
It's easy to conclude that we're the only ones struggling, which can make us even less likely to admit when things aren't going well.
We may begin to believe that being capable means coping without complaint, that being positive means always looking on the bright side, or that being a good parent, partner or colleague means keeping our difficult feelings to ourselves.
But being capable doesn't mean being unaffected by life. And being positive doesn't mean having to feel positive all the time.
We're not supposed to feel happy all the time
Somewhere along the way, many of us have absorbed the idea that uncomfortable feelings are a problem to be fixed as quickly as possible.
If we're sad, we should cheer ourselves up.
If we're anxious, we should calm down.
If we're angry, we should get over it.
If we're disappointed, we should look on the bright side.
Of course, there are times when changing our perspective is helpful.
But there's a difference between finding a constructive way forward and insisting that we shouldn't feel what we're feeling in the first place.
We can love our family and still feel overwhelmed by family life.
We can be grateful for our jobs and still find them stressful.
We can be excited about a new chapter and still feel frightened by the uncertainty.
Two seemingly contradictory feelings can exist at the same time.
Acknowledging one doesn't cancel out the other.
When we tell ourselves that we shouldn't feel something, we add another layer of difficulty to the original feeling.
Now, we're not only disappointed, for example, but also frustrated with ourselves for being disappointed.
What if, instead of immediately trying to change how we feel, we allowed ourselves to acknowledge it first?
What happens when we hide our feelings?
Psychologists distinguish between experiencing an emotion and suppressing its outward expression. We might feel upset internally while making a conscious effort to ensure nobody can tell.
Research by psychologist James Gross and Robert Levenson, published in 1997, explored what happens when people deliberately suppress their emotional expressions.
Participants who tried to hide their reactions to emotional films showed changes in their physiological responses, including increased activation of the cardiovascular system during emotional films.
The finding is important because looking calm on the outside doesn't necessarily mean our bodies are calm on the inside.
Suppressing our feelings can also make it harder for others to understand what we're experiencing. If we repeatedly say we're fine, people may reasonably assume that we are. They can't respond to needs they don't know exist.
And when feelings go unacknowledged, the underlying problem may remain unresolved.
Think about the person who says everything is fine at work, even though they're increasingly frustrated by their workload.
They keep going, take on more responsibilities and tell themselves they should be able to manage.
Eventually, a relatively small request becomes the thing that pushes them over the edge.
The reaction might appear disproportionate to the immediate situation, but it makes more sense when we consider everything that came before it.
The same pattern can occur in relationships and parenting.
A parent who repeatedly ignores their own exhaustion may eventually snap over a minor incident.
Someone who avoids admitting that they're hurt may become distant or resentful instead.
This doesn't mean every emotional outburst is caused by suppressed feelings, or that we should express every emotion the moment we experience it. It means that paying attention to our emotional state can help us understand what's happening before things escalate.
Feelings are information, not instructions
An emotion doesn't always tell us exactly what's wrong, and it certainly doesn't mean we must act on it immediately. But it can give us useful information.
Frustration might prompt us to look at our expectations, workload or boundaries.
Loneliness might draw attention to a need for connection. Anxiety might signal uncertainty, a perceived threat or a situation in which we don't feel prepared.
Anger can sometimes arise when we feel unheard, disrespected or powerless. Sadness may accompany loss, disappointment or a need for comfort.
The key word is might.
Emotions have many possible causes, and understanding them requires curiosity rather than jumping to conclusions.
This is where the Whole Needs© approach becomes useful.
Rather than treating a feeling as something to eliminate, we can become curious about what it might be telling us about our needs.
Instead of asking, “How do I stop feeling like this?” we might ask, “What is happening here, and what might I need?”
Perhaps we need rest.
Perhaps we need reassurance, support, space, connection or a difficult conversation. Perhaps we need to accept that something matters to us more than we had realised.
We don't have to solve everything immediately. Sometimes, simply recognising what we're feeling is the first useful step.
Helping children understand their feelings
This matters just as much for children as it does for adults.
When a child is upset, it's tempting to rush in with reassurance.
We might tell them there's nothing to worry about, that they shouldn't be sad, or that everything will be fine.
We usually mean well. We want them to feel better.
But children also need opportunities to recognise and understand their emotions.
If every uncomfortable feeling is quickly dismissed or redirected, they may struggle to make sense of those feelings as they grow.
Imagine a child who is disappointed because they weren't invited to a birthday party. Rather than immediately telling them not to worry about it, we can acknowledge the disappointment: “That really hurts when you wanted to be included.”
We don't need to agree with every conclusion a child draws, or let every feeling dictate what happens next. We can acknowledge the feeling while still holding appropriate boundaries.
When children learn that feelings can be named, understood and worked through, they have more opportunities to develop emotional awareness and regulation.
And adults can learn the same skill at any age.
Emotional honesty doesn't mean telling everyone everything
Being emotionally honest doesn't require us to share our deepest feelings with every person who asks how we are.
We all have a right to privacy.
There are situations where keeping an answer brief is appropriate, and times when we're not ready to talk.
The important distinction is between choosing not to share something and feeling that we must pretend it doesn't exist.
Instead of automatically saying we're fine, we could try something more honest without revealing more than we're comfortable with.
“It's been a bit of a day, actually.”
“I'm dealing with a few things at the moment.”
“I'm not quite myself today, but I'll be okay.”
Or simply, “Thanks for asking. I'm not ready to talk about it just yet.”
These answers leave room for honesty while allowing us to choose our own boundaries.
We can also make it easier for others to be honest with us. When someone shares something difficult, our instinct may be to fix it, offer advice or find a positive angle.
Sometimes that's helpful.
Sometimes they simply need to feel heard.
A little curiosity can go a long way. “That sounds difficult. Do you want to tell me more?” gives someone the opportunity to talk without making them feel they need to justify or resolve their feelings straight away.
Let yourself be human
The next time someone asks how you are, you don't have to give them a full account of your emotional state.
But before answering automatically, you might pause for a moment and check in with yourself.
How am I actually feeling?
Have I been brushing something aside because I think I should be coping better?
Is there a need I've been ignoring?
You may still decide that “fine” is the answer you want to give.
That's okay.
The difference is that you've made a choice rather than simply following a habit.
We don't need to turn every feeling into a major discussion, and we don't need to be perfectly self-aware all the time. We just need to create a little more room for the truth of our own experience.
Because being okay doesn't mean always feeling good.
It means being able to recognise where we are, without judging ourselves for being there.
You don't have to pretend to be fine to be okay. Sometimes the most useful thing you can do is stop trying to feel differently, acknowledge how you actually feel, and begin there.
In summary, emotional honesty starts with recognising how we really feel, understanding what those feelings might be telling us, and responding to our needs rather than simply pushing through.
You can start with three small steps.
1. Pause and check in. Before automatically saying you're fine, take a moment to ask yourself how you actually feel. You don't need to change anything or fix anything. Just notice.
2. Get curious about what you need. If you're feeling frustrated, overwhelmed or flat, ask yourself what might be contributing to it. Do you need rest, support, space, reassurance or a conversation? You may not know the answer straight away, and that's okay.
3. Be a little more honest. You don't have to tell everyone everything. Try acknowledging how you feel to yourself, or sharing a little more with someone you trust. Even saying, “Actually, it's been a bit of a tough day” can be a start.
You don't have to pretend to be fine to be okay. Sometimes the most useful thing you can do is stop trying to feel differently, acknowledge how you actually feel, and begin there.
Psychology reference
Gross, J. J., & Levenson, R. W. (1997). Hiding feelings: The acute effects of inhibiting negative and positive emotion. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 106(1), 95–103.
Comments